"From Bad Air to Bad Water: How John Snow Uncovered the Real Culprit Behind Cholera"

I've always been fascinated by water—not the deep, open oceans or lakes where the power of currents can sweep you away in moments (those actually terrify me!). No, I’m talking about the chemistry of it. That simple H2O molecule that literally sustains life on Earth—and probably elsewhere! Water is a universal solvent that every living thing depends on, but that’s also a double-edged sword. We need water to survive, yet its quality can be a matter of life and death.

Waterborne diseases have been one of humanity’s biggest health risks for centuries. You’ve likely heard this before—bacteria, viruses, and parasites in contaminated water can wreak havoc on human health. But here’s the thing: for much of history, people didn’t understand the connection between disease and dirty water. I absolutely love the story of John Snow, the 19th-century London physician who uncovered the cause of the 1854 Soho cholera outbreak. He didn’t just crack the case—he pioneered techniques that laid the groundwork for what we now call epidemiology.

Picture London in 1854: a rapidly growing, grimy city of 2.5 million people, thanks to the Industrial Revolution. There was no real public sanitation, and the streets were littered with human and animal waste. People dumped their cesspit waste into the Thames—the same river they got their drinking water from. Unsurprisingly, people believed in the "Miasmatic Theory," which blamed diseases on inhaling bad air from rotting matter. In a stinky city like London, this made total sense to most folks. The smell alone must’ve seemed like proof enough!

But then along came John Snow, not the illegitimate son of Eddard Stark, the London anesthesiologist who wasn’t buying the whole "bad air" theory. During the 1854 cholera outbreak in Soho, he took a different approach. Using what was basically early data mapping, he pinpointed the source of the outbreak to a single water pump on Broad Street. After examining the well’s water, he found suspicious “white, flocculent particles,” which he believed were linked to the disease. As it turns out, sewage from a baby’s diaper (the first victim in that outbreak) had seeped into the well. Gross, right? But Snow used this data to convince local authorities to remove the pump handle—and the outbreak slowed.

By [1] Originally from en.wikipedia; description page is/was here., Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=403227

Despite his findings, Snow couldn’t persuade everyone that cholera was waterborne. They even put the pump handle back! But Snow wasn’t done. He compared cholera cases among Londoners who got water from two different companies—one that sourced water from a polluted part of the Thames and another from a cleaner spot upstream. And guess what? This became one of the first double-blind scientific investigations. His research led him to propose the "Germ Theory," suggesting diseases like cholera were caused by tiny, invisible pathogens in water—not "bad air." Unfortunately, the Miasmatic Theory stuck around for a while longer.

Snow laid the foundation, but it wasn’t until 1884 that Robert Koch, a German microbiologist, made the definitive connection between cholera and the bacterium found in victims' intestines. This finally validated Snow’s work and changed public health policies for good. Koch’s discovery led to cleaner water practices and drastically reduced cholera cases. Interestingly, an Italian anatomist, Filippo Pacini, had actually spotted these “vibrions” years earlier in cholera victims, but his work went largely unnoticed until Koch’s breakthrough.

This shift—from blaming "bad air" to understanding waterborne diseases—was a game-changer for public health. Today, we take clean drinking water for granted, but it’s important to remember the years of scientific struggle and the countless lives lost before we got here. Sadly, even with all our modern knowledge, over a million people still die every year from contaminated water, poor sanitation, and inadequate hygiene practices. These deaths are preventable with better water safety measures—a stark reminder of the global water crisis that still affects millions today, especially in low-income regions.

It’s crazy to think that in 2024, we’re still battling issues that John Snow and his contemporaries fought over 150 years ago. Clean water shouldn’t be a privilege—it’s a basic human right.

How confident are you in the quality of your water in your locality?

I really hope you enjoyed this post! If you did, there's plenty more where that came from. Hit the subscribe button on my site, and you'll get a heads-up every time I share a new piece.